Last week, we talked about how shared resource pools change the way IT operates the cloud environment. We mentioned that how to avoid false positive and save the maintenance costs by measuring the pool decay. Today, I am going to explain how you can avoid another major challenge in the cloud operations – outage storm.
The Outage storm typically is caused by cascading error and the lack of mechanism to detect those errors. Chances are you are not unfamiliar with this issue. In April, 2011, Amazon AWS experienced a week-long outage on many of its AWS service offerings. I examined this incident in the article – thunderstorm from Amazon reminded us the importance of weather forecast. In a nutshell, a human error diverted major network traffic to a low bandwidth management channel. This flooded the communication between many EBS nodes. Because of the built-in automation process, these nodes started to unnecessarily replicate themselves and quickly consumed all the storage resources the availability zone. Eventually it brought down not only EBS but all other services relying on it. Almost a year later, Microsoft Azure experienced a day long outage. This time, a software glitch started to trigger unnecessary built-in automation process and brought down the server nodes. You can see the similarity between these two incidents. An error happened and triggered, not intentionally, automation processes that were built for different purpose. The outage storm, without any warning, brings your cloud down.
So how you can detect and stop the cascading as soon as possible? Let’s look at these two incidents. The environment seemed normal during the onset. The capacity in the pool seemed good. I/O was normal. The services run from these pools were not impacted. You felt everything was under control since you were monitoring the availability of each of those resources. Suddenly, you started to notice number of events showing up in your screen. While you were trying to make sense on these events, there were more and more events coming in and alerting you the availability of many devices were gone. Not long, the service help desk tickets swamped in. Customers started to complain large number of their services experiencing performance degradation. Everything happened just so fast that you didn’t get time to understand the root cause and make necessary adjustment. Sounds a nightmare to you?
How one can prevent that from happening? My suggestion is that you need to two thing. One, you need to measure the pool health. Particularly, in this case, you need to monitor the distribution of health status of its member resources. How many of them are in trouble? Do you see any trend how the trouble is propagated? What’s the rate of this propagation? Case in point, the Azure incident could have lasted longer and impacted more customers if Microsoft team hadn’t implemented its “human investigate” threshold. But still it lasted more than 12 hours. The main reason was these thresholds rely on the availability monitoring through periodic pings. And it took three timeouts in a row to trigger the threshold of the pool. And this delays the alert. So if you want to detect storm at the onset, the second thing you need to do is to detect the abnormality of behavior for its member resources, not just the ping. Combining these two measurements, the device can reflect their abnormality health status and the pool can detect the changes of the health distribution among its member resources. You, as an IT operation person, can set up rules to alert you when the health distribution changes across a critical threshold.
How does this benefit you? First you can get the alerts once that threshold is crossed even if the overall performance and capacity of the pool seem good. You will then have enough time to respond, for example diverting services to another pool or have the troubled devices quarantined. In addition, you won’t be swamped by massive alerts from each affected devices and try to guess which one you should look first. You can execute root cause analyses right from that alert at your pool level.
Cloud is built with the automation as the main mechanism to ensure its elasticity and agility. But occasionally, like what happened in these two incidents, errors can amplify their damages through cascading very quickly through those automation. Because of its inherited nature, the outage storm is more often than you think. If you operate a cloud environment, chances are you will face them pretty soon. You need to find a solution that can detect resource health by learning its behavior and can measure the distribution change of those health status at the pool level. The shared pool changes how you operate your cloud environment. Operation solution needs to evolve to help you better measure pool decay and detect outage storm. Cloud-wash is not going to cut it.
To see how it works in a real world, you can visit BMC booth (#701) in this year’s VMworld. You can see a live demo on how to detect a outsage storm at the onset and get some ideas how you would approach these problems. If you want to discuss this with me, please let the booth staff know.